Gartner details the MQ process

Magic Quadrant ChartFollowing some debate on Quora ( How much does it cost to be included in Gartner Magic Quadrant?,  do make sure you check Nancy Erskine’s answer), Lydia Leong from Gartner did publish a very useful blog post on The process of a Magic Quadrant.

Gartner’s MQ continues to be the source of much debate, mostly since it pits vendors against each others some are bound to be disappointed (a MQ with all vendors in the leaders quadrant won’t probably be of much use to IT buyers).
Gartner has overhauled the process in the last 5 years and made it quite robust now, though the weightings and ratings are still not publicised (a key difference with Forrester’s wave and IDC’s Decision matrixShort List).

No one asked for my opinions, so here they are:

  • it’s better to be in than not, even if in the niche quadrant
  • an MQ is better than a Marketscope (I don’t like rating vendors against a linear scale because it implies you should choose the one to the right)
  • an MQ is still only 2 dimensions (hear below Gideon Gartner on this point)
  • allocate enough time, about 100-120 man hours per MQ on the vendor side
  • make sure you manage your constituents expectations and get their support
  • IIAR members should read @edgyurko’s Best Practice Paper (link below)

Does this help? What is your experience? Do you have any tips?

Related posts:

 

13/1/11 edit: corrected the “IDC MQ” name after Vuk’s comment (below).

Share this...Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInEmail this to someoneShare on Google+Pin on Pinterest

, , , , , ,

5 Responses to Gartner details the MQ process

  1. Vuk Thursday 13th January 2011 at 13:01 #

    Small correction – Decision Matrix is not an IDC product, it’s published Ovum.

    • ludovic Thursday 13th January 2011 at 13:11 #

      Oops. sorry Vuk, meant the IDC Short List.

  2. Data Quality Software Saturday 9th July 2011 at 08:33 #

    Oracle and IBM are also in the Leaders quadrant with Oracle ahead of IBM but behind Teradata.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Gartner publishes MQ FAQ « The IIAR Blog - Friday 11th January 2013

    [...] Gartner details the MQ process [...]

  2. Wrap-up: Netscout vs. Gartner re. Magic Quadrant positioning | The IIAR Blog - Friday 15th August 2014

    […] Gartner details the MQ process […]

Leave a Reply